Four motorcyclists crashed after thousands of gallons of human waste spilled across a Kentucky interstate in 2022; four years later, an appeals court has upheld their combined $11 million pain-and-suffering award
A motorcycle journey through Kentucky turned into a horrific accident when thousands of gallons of human waste spilled onto an interstate highway, causing four riders to lose control and crash. The four motorcyclists were travelling at highway speeds when they encountered the dark, slippery material, fell from their bikes and slid across the contaminated road. All four suffered physical injuries and emotional distress, leading to a negligence lawsuit against the waste management company responsible for transporting the material.In a November 13, 2026, decision in Freedom Waste Services, LLC v. McAlpin, available on Justia, the Kentucky Court of Appeals upheld a jury’s combined $11 million award for pain and suffering. The company had challenged the verdict, arguing that the damages were excessive and that errors during the trial had affected the jury’s decision. However, the appeals court found insufficient grounds to order a new trial and affirmed the Lyon Circuit Court’s judgment.
Waste spilled from truck onto Interstate 24
The incident happened on May 31, 2022, when James H. Watts, a professional truck driver employed by Freedom Waste Services, collected a full container of human waste from the Oak Grove Sewer Plant. The container was being transported to the company’s landfill in Mayfield, Kentucky. It was designed with a latching mechanism and additional safety features, including a pin and safety chains, to prevent its door from opening during transportation.Around 30 miles into the journey, Watts noticed that waste was leaking from the container onto both lanes of Interstate 24. He pulled over, contacted his manager and attempted to secure the door using a strap to stop further leakage. Meanwhile, five motorcyclists travelling westbound behind the truck encountered the spilled material. They were riding at speeds of approximately 60 to 70 miles per hour when the slippery substance became trapped in their tyre treads, causing them to lose traction and crash.The riders were thrown from their motorcycles onto the road and slid through the human waste. Although they were wearing approved helmets and protective equipment, all four plaintiffs sustained injuries.
Motorcyclists described injuries and medical treatment
Five motorcyclists initially filed a negligence lawsuit against Freedom Waste and Watts in April 2023. One of them, Joseph Von Herring, settled his claim before trial. The four remaining plaintiffs were Joseph McAlpin, David Hendriks, Jerry White and Mark Mudryk. Their injuries included bruises, abrasions and broken bones. The road rash they suffered was particularly serious because their wounds had been exposed to the contaminated material.According to the court record, their treatment involved medications, antibiotics, vaccinations and injections. Several underwent wound debridement procedures to remove contaminated material from their injuries. Some also required surgery or physical therapy and continued experiencing pain. The accident also caused emotional distress. The riders described the trauma of the crash and witnessing one of their fellow motorcyclists lying motionless on the road.During the trial, Freedom Waste acknowledged its responsibility to secure the transported load and prevent material from spilling onto public roads. However, the company argued that it had taken reasonable precautions and that the accident was unforeseeable.
Jury awarded $11 million for pain and suffering
The case went before a jury in May 2025. On May 29, the jury found that both Watts and Freedom Waste had failed in their duties and that their failures substantially contributed to the motorcyclists’ injuries. The jury awarded McAlpin $3.5 million in pain-and-suffering damages, while Hendriks, White and Mudryk each received $2.5 million. Together, the awards totalled $11 million.The company challenged the verdict, arguing that the amounts were excessive compared with the riders’ medical expenses. It also questioned the admission of a photograph showing repairs made to the container’s latching mechanism the day after the accident.However, the appeals court found that the photograph was properly used to challenge Watts’s recollection of the container’s condition before the spill. He had previously identified a component in the photograph as being present before the accident, although it had actually been added afterwards.
Appeals court rejects company’s request for new trial
Freedom Waste also argued that comments made by the motorcyclists’ lawyers and other evidence presented during the trial had unfairly influenced the jury. The appeals judges rejected these arguments, finding that the company had failed to raise timely objections to several of the issues it later challenged. They also concluded that the jury’s pain-and-suffering awards were supported by the evidence and that the trial court had not clearly erred in refusing a new trial.On November 13, 2026, the Kentucky Court of Appeals unanimously affirmed the Lyon Circuit Court’s judgment. The decision means the combined $11 million pain-and-suffering award remains upheld, alongside the separately awarded medical expenses. The appeals court did not order a new trial or reduce the damages.